Comprehensive evaluation of HP Inc. (HPQ)

---

🧩 1. Understandable Business – (Buffett, Lynch, Graham)

HP Inc. operates two primary segments: Personal Systems (laptops, desktops, workstations) and Printing (consumer and commercial printers, supplies, and services). The business model is straightforward, built around product sales and recurring supply revenues. It's a classic case of a legacy tech hardware firm adapting to shifts in demand and innovation (e.g., AI-driven PCs and hybrid work).

• Simple and Predictable: Yes.
• Essential vs. Discretionary: Commercial systems are essential; consumer printers are more discretionary.
• Clarity: The company's operations can be explained in a few clear sentences.
• Verdict: ✅ Pass

---

🛡️ 2. Durable Competitive Advantage – (Buffett, Munger, Lynch)

HP's moat lies in brand recognition, global distribution, economies of scale, and in printing supplies lock-in. However, competition is fierce in both PCs and printing, with limited pricing power.

• ROE: High historical ROE (~25%), although under margin pressure recently.
• Operating Margin: Printing maintained healthy margins (around 19%); Personal Systems dropped due to tariffs (4.5%).
• Cash Flow: Recently turned negative due to tariff-related inventory shifts.
• Verdict: ⚠️ Mixed

---

🧾 3. Quantitative Value & Financial Health – (Greenblatt, Graham, Klarman)

HP trades at modest valuation multiples, suggesting potential value:

• P/E: ~11, indicating moderate valuation.
• EV/EBIT: ~9.5, reasonable versus peers.
• ROCE: Estimated near 20%.
• Debt Profile: Manageable, with short-term leverage increase due to refinancing.
• Interest Coverage: Stable.
• Verdict: ✅ Pass

---

📊 4. Growth & GARP – (Lynch, Buffett)

While the core PC and print markets are mature, HP is investing in growth areas:

• AI PCs (AIPCs): Expected to reach 25% of shipments by year-end.
• Future of Work: Emphasis on workforce solutions and digital services.
• PEG Ratio: Estimated below 1.5, aligning with GARP principles.
• Verdict: ✅ Pass

---

🌍 5. Macro & Cyclical Positioning – (Dalio, Marks)

HP is highly exposed to macro dynamics:

• Tariff Impact: Major drag on Q2 results; ~$0.12 EPS impact.
• Global Supply Chain: Rapid shift out of China to mitigate geopolitical risks.
• Economic Sensitivity: High; demand varies with economic sentiment and business cycles.
• Verdict: ⚠️ Caution

---

📉 6. Risk Aversion & Margin of Safety – (Klarman, Graham, Marks)

Risk factors are clearly visible:

• Downside: Margin compression, geopolitical risks, declining print demand.
• Mitigations: Strategic cost cuts, diversified sourcing, pricing actions.
• Valuation Buffer: Stock appears undervalued based on forward earnings.
• Verdict: ⚠️ Caution

---

🧠 7. Management Quality & Capital Allocation – (Buffett, Munger, Lynch)

Management under CEO Enrique Lores has been proactive:

• Capital Return: ~$400M returned via dividends and buybacks in Q2.
• Cost Discipline: Accelerated cost reductions and manufacturing shifts.
• Innovation: Leading in AI PCs, workforce solutions, and quantum-secure printers.
• Verdict: ✅ Pass

---

⚖️ 8. Final Valuation & Investment Decision

Valuation View:

• HP appears moderately undervalued on traditional multiples (P/E, EV/EBIT).
• Intrinsic value approximations suggest modest upside.
• With EPS expected to reach $3.00–$3.30 in FY25, and a forward P/E ~11, potential for 10–15% IRR exists if macro risks stabilize.

Verdict: ✅ Pass

---

📌 Investing Legends Scorecard Summary

---

🔍 Final Summary

HP Inc. remains a viable value play with strategic repositioning in progress. The business is well-understood, management is decisive, and the stock trades at reasonable multiples. However, geopolitical risks, declining segments like print, and cyclical demand patterns temper the bullish thesis. The company’s bets on AI, services, and operational agility are the critical catalysts for sustainable long-term upside. HP is a hold or moderate buy for investors who prioritize capital preservation with asymmetric potential over hyper-growth.